Saturday, 8 December 2012

CBSE vs ICSE - Which is better ??


A frequent debate that goes in Indian Education System is Which of the board is better CBSE(Central Board of Secondary Education) or ICSE( Indian Certificate of Secondary Education) ??

There are two very different boards of education catering to the academic sector in India, and these are CBSE (Central Board of Secondary Education) and ICSE (Indian Certificate of Secondary Education). Although the subjects taught in both boards are the same, choosing the right board is essential because this can play a significant role in the student’s future. Indians lay a lot of importance on education and knowledge, and the age old debate on choosing the right board ofeducation is bound to crop up in every household sooner or later.

Each board of education has its own set of pros and cons, and parents will have to make a calculated move taking their children’s strengths into consideration, as their future can be shaped only based on their interests.


CBSE proves to be better

 

  • CBSE is repeatitive. It  repeats the same course of study in each class or the next. This helps the student to thoroughly memorise the chapter that they study. For example, if there is a chapter named "Industrial Revolution" to be studied in class 4, the same will be taught again in class 6 or 7 with slight extra, so that children could have a revision of it.

  •  The course material of CBSE is very systematic. It goes from very basic level to higher level. This makes it very easy to study. Thats make CBSE a very easy to study, very necessary far children weaker in studies. The CBSE syllabus is a cumulative syllabus. 

  • Study courses of CBSE is not so detailed as in ICSE. That do not waste the time of student even if he / she opts out of a course. For example, if a student wants to aim for commerce in 11th grade, then he has to only read the very basic science, maths or history as required in life whereas in ICSE he has to study a lot of science and maths that will not be required in any future study.

  • After the introduction of CCE(Continuous and Comprehensive Evaluation), CBSE has become a gift to students. Now they will be rated in all fields including art, sports, behaviour and not just in the field of Study.

  • CBSE study course is very up-to-date. It is always updated by the board. Latest facts, recent studies and discoveries are always added in the next year of print. In ICSE, it is not so. They follow a older course of study.

  • It satisfies parents, teachers as well as students one way or the other.

  • CBSE course is very useful for competitive exams. Major competitive exams like IIT-JEE, NDA, etc. are designed on the basis of CBSE pattern

There definitely must be something I have missed that CBSE better course to study in.


Alas! CBSE has its own limits


 Source of this section
  •  The students who study in CBSE boards are less smarter as compared to kids studying in ICSE boards.

  • Not much focus is laid on inculcating practical knowledge in students. The CBSE syllabus also does not lay as much emphasis on core English knowledge as its counterpart does, choosing to lay more importance on the disciplines of mathematics and science.

  • The subjects in a CBSE syllabus are approached in a theoretical manner, and true emphasis is not laid on real-life concepts behind the science. Although the syllabus is application oriented, it does not provide room for effective understanding.

ICSE Pros : 

  •  Children studying in ICSE board are able to compete better in field of management and international studies, i.e, ICSE prepares children for International Competiton.

  • Students studying in ICSE school get international status.

  • ICSE course is deeper and lengthier that help student to have a better knowledge on a particular subject.


What do I prefer ??

 


I have studied both the courses and truely speaking I had really liked CBSE because it was so easy and I got so much time to do something else apart from studies. I feel CBSE is better than ICSE.
It all depends on you what you choose. Which course do you prefer?? Mention in Comments

22 comments:

  1. CBSE board is nothing infront of ICSE board from my point of view.I have studied both the boards and found ICSE best because this board teach children deeply every subject including moral science as a subject so that a child should gain some Moral Values too and it has G.K as a subject so that a child can gain some knowledge too.CBSE only repeats the education i.e. it has same course in 8th,9th,10th.A typical student of CBSE knows nothing and due to its grading system children don't study because they know that they will pass...But grading system is not in ICSE.So,Children study in order to get pass out.ICSE board declares it's result faster than CBSE so that children can plan their future according to their result.CBSE 12th class result is not out yet...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So you think learning deeply is better. So tell me how much would you remember that you have learned once you turned 18. You would forget everything that you have learned. Repeatition makes you remember somewhat more. That's what CBSE does.

      Declaring the results early doesn't make you ready to decide your future. Don't you know what skills you have even before the results are declared.

      You have studied from ICSE board and still you have so many errors in your English. How?

      Delete
    2. Profiler is right. CBSE has over 3 million candidates for 12th exams whereas ICSE has somewhere about 1.5 million candidates. Thus evaluation of marks in CBSE takes longer.

      Now ICSE results are out within 45 days of exams whereas CBSE results are out within 60 days of exams. In this term, CBSE id far better..

      Delete
  2. Every one has different opinions. ICSE and CBSE both have its own advantages and disadvantages. I will not praise any of the board though I am an ICSE student. I wanted to put forward a question " I am opting for commerce with maths in 11th standard. Which board should go for ?". Most of your blog speaks in favour of CBSE board and I am pretty sure that you would recommend me the same but I wanted to know the advantages for a "commerce" student if she opts CBSE board.
    Lately I have been searching for the same question and I did not get the right answer.
    I was just going through the comments and I read the first two. The blogger said "You have studied from ICSE board and still you have so many errors in your English. " Yeah it is right that ICSE student's english is good but every board has different kind of students some are good in english some in mathematics and so on.You cannot blame the board for that. No offence just a question. It is a humble request please answer my question as soon as possible.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I believe that upto class 8 or 10, it doesn't matter which school you belong to or which board you studied from. Elementary and middle school education is basically same. Difference start from secondary education.

      CBSE becomes equally tough as ICSE in class 11 and 12. Moreover CBSE syllabus is more competition oriented and greatly reliable for all. If you need a job ( of course you do), then go for CBSE. If you ask about syllabus, then CBSE has excellent coverage of commercial topics in the three subjects namely Accountancy, Business Studies and Economics.

      Maths is much broadly covered in ICSE. Most of B.Sc. topics are covered by class 12. CBSE is liberal in this case as only topics required for understanding other subjects are only covered. Thus you would have advantage of not studying useless topics if you join CBSE. Rest depends on your own decision.

      Delete
    2. Thank you for the advice.
      I will definitely think about it.

      Delete
  3. Thanks for the useful information. I really appreciate your hard work and effort, and the way you have explained the topic. Great work. Keep it up.

    CBSE Results 2015

    ReplyDelete
  4. hey nice question!!the board would be any it is the child ability to learn more....for my kid the icse board syllabus refrence books online are helpfull during exams for refrence.I show you few sites to download:
    http://www.genextstudents.com/studyzone/
    www.tutor.com
    buddyschool.com

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am student of 9th cbse and thinking about joining icse in class 11th. I am a good in studies according to cbse board and manages to secure 2nd or 3rd rank in class. Can I go for icse to improve English efficiency. Will the course be same for 11th and 12th as I want to go in the fields of aeronautical engineering and second choice is IIT

    ReplyDelete
  6. The CBSE board is short form of Central Board of Secondary Education. It prepares the syllabus for students up to Class 12. The curriculum is set by National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT). The board conducts India's two nation-wide board examinations: the All India Secondary School Examination for Class 10 and the All India Senior School Certificate Examination for Class 12. Many schools are affiliated to CBSE syllabus.

    The ICSE is short form of Indian Certificate for Secondary Education. It was established by the University of Cambridge Local Examinations Syndicate. The council conducts an all India exam for Class 10 called ICSE(Indian Certificate for Secondary Education) and for class 12 called the Indian School Certificate (ISC).

    A common misconception is that CBSE and ICSE are both education boards similar to SSC boards of state government. CBSE is an education board but ICSE is the certificate offered after completion of the course and it is not a board. Still ICSE board is commonly used to mention this course.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Looking forward to reading more. Great article post. Cool.
    CBSE 10th Result

    ReplyDelete
  8. nice blog...Best SEO training in hyderabad all modules are clearly solved and practice with guide.seo training in hyderabadAnd clearly getting knowledge of seo.

    ReplyDelete
  9. its really great information Thank you sir And keep it up More Post
    Indian Super League Live

    Awesome stuff is being shared by you
    Indian Super League Fixtures

    I must say indeed an awesome post and just loved the whole read.
    ISL Fixtures

    Very much interesting to read such a nice a posting / article
    ISL Live

    ReplyDelete
  10. The post is useful and it would really help for those who search for AICTE approved colleges | Top b schools

    ReplyDelete
  11. Exclusive Collection of Salwar Suit and Many More…
    We Have Some For You In Your Budget For more…
    Plz visit:- Ramzan Mubarak 2017

    ReplyDelete
  12. Have Lovely and Beautiful Salwar Suit And Many More…
    We Have Some For You In Your Budget For more…
    Plz visit:- sarees Online

    ReplyDelete